A yes no maybe list for couples is a checklist of things you might do together, from slow kissing to light bondage, that each of you marks privately as yes, no or maybe. Then you compare. The magic is that nobody has to blurt out, “So… what do you think about handcuffs?” The list does the asking, and you only need to talk about the places where your answers meet.

Below you’ll find a free, four-tier list (romantic, sensual, adventurous, kinky) that you can finish in one sitting, plus a step-by-step method to compare answers so you see only what you both want. We’ll also cover what to do with the maybes, which is where most of the good stuff hides.

🔥 Want to try it tonight? Spiced Couple is a free game for two: no download, your partner joins from one link.

Play Free Now

What a Yes No Maybe List Is (and Where It Came From)

The format has been around in sex education and kink communities for years. One of the most widely shared versions is Scarleteen’s “Yes, No, Maybe So” sexual inventory by Heather Corinna and CJ Turett, first published in 2010 and still updated. It’s long and thorough, with codes beyond yes, no and maybe, like “F” for things you enjoy fantasizing about but don’t necessarily want to do.

The couples version is simpler. Every item gets one of three answers:

People also call it a sex bucket list, a things to try in bed list or, when it leans heavily into BDSM, a kink checklist for couples. Whatever the name, it does two jobs at once: it gives you new ideas, and it gives you a low-pressure way to share desires that are hard to bring up in conversation.

Before You Start: Three Ground Rules

Spend two minutes on these before anyone picks up a pen. They’re what keep the exercise fun instead of tense.

  1. No comments on solo answers. If one of you marks yes and the other marks no, that item simply disappears. Nobody asks “why did you say no to that?” and nobody gets teased for a lone yes.
  2. A yes is not a promise. Marking yes means “open to it,” not “we’re doing this Saturday.” Consent still happens in the moment, every time, and either of you can change your mind.
  3. Answer for now, not forever. Go with what feels true this month. You can redo the list later, and your answers will probably shift.

Agree on these out loud. It sounds formal, but it’s what lets both of you answer honestly.

The Free Yes No Maybe List: 60 Ideas in Four Tiers

Copy the list into a notes app or print it twice so each of you has your own copy. Mark every item Y, N or M. The numbers matter: they’re what you’ll compare later, so keep them the same on both copies.

The tiers go from gentle to bold. You don’t have to fill in all four. Plenty of couples stop after tier two the first time, and that’s a perfectly good result.

Tier 1: Romantic

  1. A long, slow kiss with no expectation of anything else
  2. Slow dancing in the kitchen
  3. A bath or shower together
  4. Full-body massage with oil
  5. Writing each other a love letter
  6. A no-phones date night at home
  7. Sleeping naked
  8. Cuddling and talking about favorite memories
  9. Breakfast in bed
  10. Recreating your first date
  11. A weekend away with no plans
  12. Holding eye contact during sex
  13. Saying “I love you” during sex
  14. Morning sex before work
  15. A playlist made just for the bedroom

Tier 2: Sensual

  1. Undressing each other slowly
  2. Sexting during the day
  3. Sending a flirty photo
  4. Making out somewhere new in the house
  5. Mutual masturbation
  6. Watching each other touch yourselves
  7. Showing your partner exactly how you like to be touched
  8. Trying a new position
  9. Using a vibrator together
  10. Shopping for a toy together
  11. Wearing lingerie or something you feel sexy in
  12. Oral sex (giving)
  13. Oral sex (receiving)
  14. Sex with the lights fully on
  15. Describing a fantasy out loud

Tier 3: Adventurous

  1. Sex somewhere other than the bedroom
  2. Dirty talk
  3. Blindfolds
  4. Watching porn together
  5. Reading erotica aloud to each other
  6. A strip tease
  7. Sex in front of a mirror
  8. Recording audio or video for your eyes only, deleted the moment either of you asks
  9. Role play (strangers at a bar, a new hire and the boss)
  10. A sex dice or card game
  11. Edging, where one of you is brought close to orgasm and made to wait
  12. Anal play with fingers or a toy
  13. Shower or bath sex
  14. Planning a whole evening around one partner’s pleasure
  15. Ice, feathers or other sensation play

Tier 4: Kinky

  1. Light spanking
  2. Soft wrist cuffs or a silk tie
  3. One partner taking charge and giving instructions
  4. Being told what to do
  5. Hair pulling (gentle, from the base of the scalp)
  6. Praise (“good job,” “you look incredible”) during sex
  7. Light degradation or teasing language, negotiated ahead of time
  8. Orgasm control or denial
  9. Being tied to the bed
  10. Using a safeword system, such as green, yellow, red
  11. Wearing a collar or other symbol during a scene
  12. Pegging or strap-on play
  13. Nipple clamps
  14. A scene that starts with a written “script”
  15. Talking with another couple about kink (no playing, just talking)

Anything in tier four deserves a real conversation and a safeword before you try it. Keep restraints loose enough to slip two fingers under, never leave a partner who’s tied up alone, and keep spanking to fleshy areas like the butt and thighs. If several kinky items come back as matches, look for a dedicated kink checklist for couples or a beginner-friendly BDSM guide before going further.

Turn Your Shared Yeses Into Tonight's Game

Pick the level in The Spicy Challenge that matches your list, from Romantic to Hard. One of you sends a link, you both see the same challenge in real time, and it's free.

🔥 Play Spiced Couple Free — No Download

How to Use a Yes No Maybe List Without Hurt Feelings

The list is the easy part. The comparison is where couples get nervous, because nobody wants to see their partner say no to something they secretly want. The trick is to set things up so you only ever see the overlaps.

Step 1: Fill It Out Separately

Sit in different rooms or at least different ends of the couch. Give yourselves 15 to 20 minutes and don’t compare as you go. If an item confuses you, mark it maybe and keep moving.

Step 2: Compare Only the Matches

You have two good options, depending on how private you want the reveal to be.

Option A: The matches-only spreadsheet. In Google Sheets, make three tabs named “Partner A,” “Partner B” and “Matches.” On both partner tabs, put a header in row 1 and paste the 60 items into column A, rows 2 to 61, in the same order. Each of you types Y, M or N in column B of your own tab. Then paste this formula into cell A1 of the Matches tab:

=FILTER('Partner A'!A2:A61, 'Partner A'!B2:B61<>"N", 'Partner B'!B2:B61<>"N", 'Partner A'!B2:B61<>"", 'Partner B'!B2:B61<>"")

The Matches tab lists only the items you both answered with Y or M. Anything one of you marked N, or left blank, never shows up. (If you have no overlaps at all, the cell shows a “No matches” error instead of a list.) Hide the two partner tabs and agree not to open each other’s. Hidden tabs aren’t locked, so this runs on trust, but it keeps the reveal to matches only.

Option B: The paper read-out. One partner reads out the numbers they marked Y or M. The other says “match” if they marked the same item Y or M, or simply “next” if not. Switch readers for each tier so the exposure is shared. Remember the ground rule: no reactions to a “next.”

Either way, once you have your list of matches, take turns saying whether each one was a yes or a maybe for you. That’s what you need for the next step.

Step 3: Sort Your Matches Into Three Piles

Your answers What it means What to do
Yes + Yes Green light Put it on your sex bucket list for couples and pick one for this week
Yes + Maybe Curious overlap Talk about the maybe’s conditions first
Maybe + Maybe Shared curiosity Explore slowly, maybe as fantasy talk before action

Anything with a no in it never makes the table. That’s the whole point.

What to Do With the “Maybes”

Maybes are the most interesting part of any yes no maybe list. They usually mean “yes, if.” The job is to find the “if.”

Take one maybe at a time and ask each other a few easy questions:

A maybe for “being tied to the bed” might become a yes for “wrists held down with hands, ten minutes, lights on.” A maybe for “role play” might start as a text conversation before it ever happens in person. The yes, no, maybe guide from Sex With Emily makes the same point: talking through your maybes is often how they turn into yeses.

And sometimes a maybe stays a maybe. That’s fine. Curiosity you can share is already intimacy, even if you never act on it.

If You Have Very Few Matches

A thin list can sting, but it’s rarely a sign of real incompatibility. More often:

Whatever happens, don’t argue over the list itself. It’s a conversation starter, not a scorecard.

Turning Your List Into Real Plans

A finished list is only useful if something comes out of it. Here’s a simple rhythm:

  1. Pick one green light per week. Start small. A double yes from tier one or two is a great opener.
  2. Schedule one maybe conversation per month. Fifteen minutes, no pressure to act.
  3. Debrief after anything new. What did you like? What would you change? Keep it light and specific.
  4. Revisit the whole list every six to twelve months. Scarleteen calls your answers a snapshot of one point in time and expects them to change.

If you’d rather not plan, let a game do it. Your shared yeses tell you which level to choose in The Spicy Challenge: mostly tier one and two matches point to Romantic or Spicy, while a full tier three or four suggests Fire or Hard. Treat your maybes as soft dares to try next time, and you’ve turned a checklist into an evening. For more ideas in the same spirit, see our roundup of intimacy games for couples and these ways to spice up your relationship.

Why This Works Better Than “So, What Do You Want?”

Asking a partner what they want in bed often gets a shrug, not because they don’t know, but because answering means taking a risk. A list removes that risk. Both of you show your cards at the same time, and only the matching ones turn face up.

It also tends to surprise people. Couples who have been together for years often find a few double yeses they never knew about. That’s part of what keeps a long relationship interesting: there’s always more to learn about the person next to you. If that idea appeals to you, our piece on how to discover new sides of your partner goes deeper.

So print two copies, pour something nice and give yourselves twenty minutes. The worst case is a good conversation. The best case is a list of things you both want and finally know about.

Sources & Further Reading